India.Arie Says Gaga, Beyonce 'Telephone' Video 'Went Too Far'

Neo-soul singer India.Arie is not a fan of Lady Gaga and Beyonce's 'Telephone' music video, and decided to share her thoughts via her Twitter. Although Arie, acknowledged that she understands Gaga's avant-garde style, she feels the video, is a little too far out for her taste.

"Don't be offended, this is all MY opinion ... Am I the only one who thinks the 'telephone' video is going a bit too far?" she pondered. "I'm not referring to the abstract nature of the video ... I'm talking about the IMAGERY -- the unspoken back story, the language the message. I agree Gaga is being her image. I dig her creative mind But still ... [There's] a such thing as socially irresponsible. I'm just sayin."

Gaga, recently explained the video's content and underlining meanings. "There's certainly always a hidden message in my music videos. But I would say most predominately, I'm always trying to convolute everyone's idea of what a pop music video should be," she said in an interview.

In the 9-minute clip Gaga and Beyonce pay homage to director Quentin Tarantino's films, 'Pulp Fiction' and 'Kill Bill,' playing two femme fatales that kill guests in a diner before running away together in their "P---- Wagon." According to Arie, the video, which includes a scant wardrobe and sexual undertones, is unappealing. "I don't live under a rock and I get that a lot of work put into it. I'm talking social responsibility. There's an artist ever 10 years who pushes the envelope ... but its bout to fall off the table. When is it too far? I respect the creative mind but disagree with the 'choices' as a dish meant to be served for mass consumption."

Produced by Rodney Jerkins, 'Telephone' was released on Gaga's second album 'The Fame Monster' a follow-up to her multi-platinum debut 'The Fame.'


CHECK OUT THE CONCERT
N/A N/A
N/A
Starting from N/A
Average Price N/A
SEE MORE TICKETS »
UPCOMING SHOWS IN YOUR AREA
- -
-
- -
-
- -
-

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

148 Comments

Filter by:
quashae212

I just thought that the video was creative, but very stupid. It didn't go with the song at all.

March 30 2010 at 10:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mae

Please excuse the typos...not everyone is a secretary...LOL

March 30 2010 at 4:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mae

I have no words for the stupidity of this video. I rarely if ever even watch the mindless things, but after reading India Arie's critique of it, I decided I would. I am appalled at Beyonce's choice to even be a party to something so completely degrading, and just plain stupid. Not that I have ever been a big fan of hers, but I did expect more....it's time to grow up Beyonce and act like a lady. No one wants to see the crotch, dips, and butt shaking....think more of yourself dear. As for lady Gaga, when will people stop taking things they perceive to be artistic expression just because you dont understand it. What "Lady Gaga", (and I use the term lay very loose) is calling artistic freedom is an insult to art itself. Call it what it is, the longerst 9-10 minutes of my life, and time I will never see again. It is time for us as a nation to get some business about ourselves.....no wonder everyone despises us. We bask in our own arrogance.

March 30 2010 at 4:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
charita

stop whining america, it a video for goodness sake. get over it..... now slowly move away from the computer and go outside and PLAY!

March 30 2010 at 3:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mark

Both ladies are bisexual. Lady GaGa mentions it in an interview. She said I really wanted Beyonce in the video because we both love women.

March 30 2010 at 11:55 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
dumanbeing

Ga-Ga is burning too fast to last...simple. She is setting herself up to have to go farther and farther into the perverse and disgusting. It's unfortunate because she does have real musical talent but, similar to the bad artistic decisions Alicia Keyes has made, we forget they actually are trained pianist and writers.

Beyonce jumping on this incinerate's [Ga-Ga's]video was a bad decision even though she did not expose herself like Ga-Ga did, it made her seem cheap and unpolished. What you do in your 20s, you regret in your 30's and 40's when your children see it.

March 29 2010 at 1:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ashante

Just reading the comments made on this article, I am amazed at how quickly people rely on insulting each other, simply because they can't get their own opinions across.

It's really quite disgusting. And this is coming from a teenager, reading the text of "adults". Way to set an example.

Jesus, and you all are worried about the effect Gaga will have on the younger generation? Look at yourselves.

March 26 2010 at 6:07 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
judy maestas

What are they but two clothes horses in love with the camera. Beyonce has a nice voice, but lately she just looks trampy. Gaga is just that, gaga, or nuts. Idiots.

March 25 2010 at 3:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
unbelieveable

"India.Arie"?!?!? WHO THE F*** IS THAT?!? LMFAO she's just greeeeen with envy bc Gaga & Beyonce are HOT and TALENTED and she isn't...give me a break, the video is hilarious and the ladies in it look DIVINE!!! STOP HATIN!!! LOL! ;D

March 25 2010 at 12:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
the 5 members

i agree...the video made no sense i was expecting them in a club enjoying themselves and their men calling...not in a prison.i just did not expect that from 2 of the most popular woman in music to make a video like that.still love their music though...

March 25 2010 at 11:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
ADVERTISEMENT

AOL Radio

play arrow
Top Hip-Hop - Hip-hop's greatest
Snoop Dogg, Jay-Z, 50 Cent
play arrow
Top Jams - Hip-hop and crossover hits
T-Pain, Mariah Carey, Akon, Lil Wayne
play arrow
Top R&B - Today's top R&B hits
Kelly Rowland, Rihanna, T.I.

Your Settings

{email}

Subscriptions

Weekly Newsletter

The Boombox Music Blog news in your mailbox. Top Articles, reviews, photos & more.

Realtime alerts

Daily alerts


Update
Cancel
;